Showing 1-4 out of 268 reviews. Previous | Next

• From a 5-yr old's point of view -- the whole room is one room that he and his "ma" are kept. It's the only world he knows. When he learns about "outside" in real life, his words are charming and really sound like a small child would think. Loved it!

  5.00 out of 5

  pharrm

• What hold could Old Nick have over Ma that would make that room her world? Why didn't she just leave? Or maybe she wasn't able to leave?Jack's fifth birthday definitely wouldn't be what a normal five-year-old would be delighted with, but Jack was happy to spend the day with his Ma in their ordinary, same-as-always routine. They spent every day in the "room" with the food and clothing that Old Nick provided for them.Ma doesn't allow Old Nick to see Jack but she never tells Jack why. Ma and Jack's days are creatively spent inventing things, measuring everything in the room that has been Ma's space for the past seven years, reading books and changing the characters to suit them, and watching the clock so they know when it is time to eat or sleep. They never leave their "room," and Jack really doesn't know any better or know anything about the outside world except what his Ma tells him when they read books. As much as Ma tries to protect and shelter Jack, he begins to question what is beyond the walls they live in. Ma tries to divert Jack's attention to other things, but sometimes it is unavoidable......especially the night when Jack overheard a conversation between Ma and Old Nick about him and the life Old Nick provides for her. One comment made by Old Nick that stuck in my mind was: "I don't think you appreciate how good you've got it here," "Do you?" Page 69 To me that would be highly questionable....how good could life be simply living in a room and never going outside?I grew to hate Old Nick and how he treated both of them. When you find out the "whole" story, you won't want to stop reading. This book is about fear, abuse, control, a mother's love, and wanting the best for your child. At first you may want to put the book down, but don't do it....you will share Ma's feelings of fear for Old Nick and her dependence on him and also the heartbreak of Jack's acceptance of the only life he has known. You will fall in love with sweet, innocent, literal Jack, and you will think about both characters and their experience long after you turn the last page. To me this was actually a "creative" thriller...excellent storyline. I really liked the book. 5/5

  5.00 out of 5

  meadowmist

• This book was such an emotional read. I always knew that I wasn't a kid person, so reading a book told from the perspective of a five-year-old was frustrating for me at times (and the breast feeding scenes were just plain disturbing) but I was really pulled into the story. Unforgettable.

  5.00 out of 5

  Kayla-Marie

• My stomach, heart and head are still churning from this one. A real page turner, which I read in a couple of days. Amazing characters, extreme tension, well researched but not textbook in terms of psychology and developmental issues. Disturbing because we know it's a novel but also we know from the news that it is true.

  5.00 out of 5

  Chicherie

Reviews provided by Librarything.

No reviews here.