Please note: In order to keep Hive up to date and provide users with the best features, we are no longer able to fully support Internet Explorer. The site is still available to you, however some sections of the site may appear broken. We would encourage you to move to a more modern browser like Firefox, Edge or Chrome in order to experience the site fully.

Cogent Science in Context : The Science Wars, Argumentation Theory, and Habermas, Paperback / softback Book

Cogent Science in Context : The Science Wars, Argumentation Theory, and Habermas Paperback / softback

Part of the Studies in Contemporary German Social Thought series

Paperback / softback


A proposal for an interdisciplinary, context-sensitive framework for assessing the strength of scientific arguments that melds Jurgen Habermas's discourse theory and sociological contextualism. Recent years have seen a series of intense, increasingly acrimonious debates over the status and legitimacy of the natural sciences.

These "science wars" take place in the public arena-with current battles over evolution and global warming-and in academia, where assumptions about scientific objectivity have been called into question.

Given these hostilities, what makes a scientific claim merit our consideration?

In Cogent Science in Context, William Rehg examines what makes scientific arguments cogent-that is, strong and convincing-and how we should assess that cogency.

Drawing on the tools of argumentation theory, Rehg proposes a multidimensional, context-sensitive framework both for understanding the cogency of scientific arguments and for conducting cooperative interdisciplinary assessments of the cogency of actual scientific arguments.

Rehg closely examines Jurgen Habermas's argumentation theory and its implications for understanding cogency, applying it to a case from high-energy physics.

A series of problems, however, beset Habermas's approach.

In response, Rehg outlines his own "critical contextualist" approach, which uses argumentation-theory categories in a new and more context-sensitive way inspired by ethnography of science.


Save 9%



Free Home Delivery

on all orders

Pick up orders

from local bookshops


Also in the Studies in Contemporary German Social Thought series  |  View all