From the Mouth of the Whale Paperback
In the chilling aftermath of Iceland's Lutheran Reformation in 1635, Jonas Palmason - a poet, naturalist and self-taught healer - has been condemned to exile for heretical conduct. Sitting on a barren island, he contemplates his life in a country that has become gripped by feverish superstition and the cruelty of poverty.
He recalls his gift for curing 'female maladies', his exorcism of a walking corpse in the remote county of Snaefjallastrond, the frenzied massacre of innocent Basque whalers at the hands of local villagers and the death of two of his children while his family were on the run.
When his exile is suddenly revoked, Jonas finds himself swallowed and spewed from the mouth of a north whale, back onto the mainland.
There he returns to the arms of his son and ends his days writing books of poetry and legend.
Based on the historical figure Jon Gudmundsson, From the Mouth of the Whale is a magical evocation of an enlightened mind and a vanished age.
- Format: Paperback
- Pages: 275 pages
- Publisher: Telegram Books
- Publication Date: 01/05/2011
- Category: Modern & contemporary fiction (post c 1945)
- ISBN: 9781846590832
Showing 1 - 5 of 11 reviews.
Previous | Next
Review by JBD1
I've generally not had very good luck when I try to get into Icelandic fiction, but Sjón's "From the Mouth of the Whale" (English translation by Victoria Cribb published by Telegram in 2011) was really quite an enjoyable read. Perhaps it was the historical nature of the narrative that appealed to me, or maybe the natural history elements that the author incorporated into the text. But I liked it. The stream-of-consciousness style worked for me in a way it usually doesn't, and Sjón's lyrical depiction of 17th-century Iceland is lovely. It helps, I'm sure, that the great historical character Ole Worm makes an extended cameo appearance.Definitely worth a try if you tend to like historical fiction with lots of natural history worked in.
Review by auntmarge64
A bleak tale of early 17th century Iceland, told by an old man banished to solitary exile after his conviction for witchcraft. The story is told primarily in a stream-of-consciousness, and there is little that is positive or beautiful in Jónas Pálmason’s mind or memory. I think there are some readers who will find this story fascinating for its imagery and imagination, but I could not appreciate the unremitting grimness.
Review by Smiler69
Review by joririchardson
In 17th Century Iceland, Jónas Pálmason's strange way of life casts him into a suspicion. His old pagan beliefs, superstitions, extensive learning, and naturalism are believed by many to be sorcery, and so he is sent into exile.When I saw the description of this book, I knew that I had to read it. I have read few books about Iceland, and certainly never one about Iceland in the 1600's. Also, the publisher is known for printing strange, atypical books that I more often than not find myself loving.Well, "From the Mouth of the Whale" was indeed strange, though not for the same reasons as the other books I had read. It was a stream of consciousness type of book, which I normally either love or hate. Here, I hated it. It prevented me from becoming absorbed in the book. Whenever I would put it down and then pick it back up again, I would find the style jarring, and it would take about 50 pages to get used to it. By then, it would be time to stop - and so it went until I finished, feeling sore as if I had just commenced a bumpy ride.It's a shame, because if not for the distracting writing style, I think that I could have really enjoyed this book. I think that naturalism can be quite interesting, especially in a historical setting. And Sjon often included intricate plot descriptions of animals that directly related to the story or characters. Also, I loved the opening scene, in which Lucifer first meets man. Sjon's version of a young Satan is a son of God, which I found intriguing. Satan is Jesus' brother? It sounds like a story. Satan's foreboding feeling regarding man, predicting their selfishness and insistence on destroying the rest of God's creation, was apt and insightful.I was annoyed that Lucifer never again appeared in the story, and his cameo seemed irrelevant except for proving a point.There were other enticingly interesting little things scattered throughout the book. Learned scholars study "unicorn's horns" and "mermaid sculptures," actually narwhale tusks and coral. Jónas' superstitions and pagan beliefs were intriguing. Occasional paragraphs about natural things pepper the story, almost always intertwined with magic. Jónas compares himself extensively to a sandpiper - does this mean something?Everything I felt mildly interesting in this book never led to anything, and it was never enough to overpower the distaste I felt toward the writing style.I wouldn't recommend this book unless you personally love stream of consciousness novels. If so, there is plenty to be enjoyed. However, if you, like me, find the writing style more likely to range from distracting to infuriating, it would perhaps be best to skip this one.
Review by lazybee
I wanted to like this book - I like historical fiction and Iceland is a really interesting country, so I thought Icelandic historical fiction would be really interesting. But I just could not get into it, the writing style was really annoying. The book is full of long rambling paragraphs sprinkled with ellipses, which are just hard to read and made it unclear what was happening. It's possible that people who really like fiction written in a stream of consciousness style would like From the Mouth of the Whale, but it is definitely not for everyone.
Previous | Next